Divergent Propagation Networks Define Two Pathophysiologically Distinct Electroclinical Phenotypes in Mesial Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

Background and Purpose Temporal dissociation between electrographic and clinical seizure onset in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE) implies network heterogeneity. We hypothesized that MTLE consists of distinct electroclinical phenotypes defined by divergent seizure propagation dynamics. Methods We retrospectively analyzed 167 seizures from 13 patients with drug-resistant MTLE who achieved Engel Class I surgical outcomes. Based on the predominant relationship between scalp electroencephalography (EEG) and clinical onset, patients were classified as EEG-first (n=7) or Clinical-first (n=6). Seizure onset patterns, propagation pathways, and temporal dynamics were assessed using scalp and stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG). Results The cohort included 83 scalp and 84 SEEG seizures. By definition, onset order differed: in EEG-first seizures, scalp changes preceded clinical signs in 70.5%, whereas the reverse occurred in 65.8% of Clinical-first seizures (p<0.001). EEG-first seizures demonstrated longer SEEG-to-clinical latency (28.8±7.7 s vs. 13.0±7.7 s; p=0.004) and rhythmic theta onset on scalp EEG with focal SEEG low-voltage fast activity or preictal spikes. In contrast, Clinical-first seizures showed heterogeneous scalp patterns (theta, delta–theta, or delta slowing). Propagation tended to differ, with anterior pathways more common in EEG-first (69.6%) and posterior pathways in Clinical-first (26.3%), though with partial overlap (p=0.138). Conclusions MTLE comprises two pathophysiologically distinct phenotypes: EEG-first, reflecting a slowly propagating anterior mesial network, and Clinical-first, involving a rapidly spreading posterior network. This classification offers a mechanistic framework for understanding electroclinical dissociation and may refine presurgical evaluation.